Modeling the sustainability of a ceramic water filter intervention

Authored by Jonathan Mellor, Rebecca Dillingham, Lydia Abebe, Beeta Ehdaie, James Smith

Date Published: 2014-02-01

DOI: 10.1016/j.watres.2013.11.035

Sponsors: United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) United States National Institutes of Health (NIH) United States National Science Foundation (NSF)

Platforms: NetLogo

Model Documentation: Other Narrative Flow charts

Model Code URLs: http://www.sciencedirect.com.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/science/MiamiMultiMediaURL/1-s2.0-S0043135413009846/1-s2.0-S0043135413009846-mmc1.pdf/271768/html/S0043135413009846/bfd252578e6f3e4b4bb6582acf675023/mmc1.pdf

Abstract

Ceramic water filters (CWFs) are a point-of-use water treatment technology that has shown promise in preventing early childhood diarrhea (ECD) in resource-limited settings. Despite this promise, some researchers have questioned their ability to reduce ECD incidences over the long term since most effectiveness trials conducted to date are less than one year in duration limiting their ability to assess long-term sustainability factors. Most trials also suffer from lack of blinding making them potentially biased. This study uses an agentbased model (ABM) to explore factors related to the long-term sustainability of CWFs in preventing ECD and was based on a three year longitudinal field study. Factors such as filter user compliance, microbial removal effectiveness, filter cleaning and compliance declines were explored. Modeled results indicate that broadly defined human behaviors like compliance and declining microbial effectiveness due to improper maintenance are primary drivers of the outcome metrics of household drinking water quality and ECD rates. The model predicts that a ceramic filter intervention can reduce ECD incidence amongst under two year old children by 41.3%. However, after three years, the average filter is almost entirely ineffective at reducing ECD incidence due to declining filter microbial removal effectiveness resulting from improper maintenance. The model predicts very low ECD rates are possible if compliance rates are 80-90%, filter log reduction efficiency is 3 or greater and there are minimal long-term compliance declines. Cleaning filters at least once every 4 months makes it more likely to achieve very low ECD rates as does the availability of replacement filters for purchase. These results help to understand the heterogeneity seen in previous intervention-control trials and reemphasize the need for researchers to accurately measure confounding variables and ensure that field trials are at least 2-3 years in duration. In summary, the CWF can be a highly effective tool in the fight against ECD, but every effort should be made by implementing agencies to ensure consistent use and maintenance. (C) 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Tags

Agent-based modeling Complex systems ABM Water Quality Africa Ceramic water filters Developing country Diarrhea ECD HWT Household water treatment POU Point-of-use WASH