Interaction effects of targeted agri-environmental payments on non-marketed goods and services under climate change in a mountain region

Authored by Huber Robert, Snell Rebecca, Monin Francois, Brunner Sibyl Hanna, Schmatz Dirk, Finger Robert

Date Published: 2017

DOI: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2017.04.029

Sponsors: No sponsors listed

Platforms: LPL

Model Documentation: Other Narrative

Model Code URLs: http://rossa-prod-ap11.ethz.ch/delivery/DeliveryManagerServlet?dps_pid=IE2609069

Abstract

Targeting of agri-environmental measures (AEMs) is a key to increasing the cost-effectiveness of governmental support for biodiversity conservation and the provision of ecosystem services from agriculture. Existing literature, however, often focuses on single measures without considering that policies are usually bundles of different measures addressing multiple non-marketed goods and services. Thus, interaction effects of a set of policies in a given policy mix may influence the cost-effectiveness of single measures. Recently, Swiss agricultural policy was redesigned using the Tinbergen rule as its basis, i.e., a single measure for each policy goal, including additional targeted direct payments. This facilitates testing for interaction effects of multiple targeted AEMs. Here we use a social-ecological, agent-based modelling framework to assess interaction effects of these agricultural policies while accounting for climate change impacts in our analysis. The results from our case study in a mountain region show that ecosystem service provision increases with targeted payments. However, interaction effects of the different targeted policies affect the provision levels of all goods and services. In particular, changes at the extensive margin, i.e., the total amount of land that is under production, largely determine the amount of ecosystem services provided. Thus, climate change driven productivity increases and policies that keep land in production may substantially support the provision of non-marketed goods and services in marginal agricultural production regions with a high potential for land abandonment. Consequently, the effectiveness of targeted policy measures should also consider changes at the extensive margin and be assessed in the context of bundles or portfolios of different policy measures.

Tags

Management Land-use change Biodiversity Ecosystem services Conservation Model Biodiversity conservation Schemes Trade-offs Agent-based modelling Agri-environmental measures Targeting Non-marketed goods and services Mountain region Agricultural landscapes Compensation payments