Cost-effectiveness of a potential Zika vaccine candidate: a case study for Colombia

Authored by Affan Shoukat, Thomas Vilches, Seyed M Moghadas

Date Published: 2018

DOI: 10.1186/s12916-018-1091-x

Sponsors: National Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) Brazilian Ministry of Education (CAPES) Canadian Foundation for Innovation

Platforms: Julia

Model Documentation: Other Narrative Mathematical description

Model Code URLs: https://github.com/affans/zika/tree/publication

Abstract

Background: A number of Zika vaccine platforms are currently being investigated, some of which have entered clinical trials. We sought to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of a potential Zika vaccine candidate under the WHO Vaccine Target Product Profile for outbreak response, prioritizing women of reproductive age to prevent microcephaly and other neurological disorders. Methods: Using an agent-based simulation model of ZIKV transmission dynamics in a Colombian population setting, we conducted cost-effectiveness analysis with and without pre-existing herd immunity. The model was parameterized with estimates associated with ZIKV infection, risks of microcephaly in different trimesters, direct medical costs, and vaccination costs. We assumed that a single dose of vaccine provides a protection efficacy in the range 60\% to 90\% against infection. Cost-effectiveness analysis was conducted from a government perspective. Results: Under a favorable scenario when the reproduction number is relatively low (R-0 = 2.2) and the relative transmissibility of asymptomatic infection is 10\% compared with symptomatic infection, a vaccine is cost-saving (with negative incremental cost-effective ratio; ICER) for vaccination costs up to US\$6 per individual without herd immunity, and up to US\$4 per individual with 8\% herd immunity. For positive ICER values, vaccination is highly cost-effective for vaccination costs up to US\$10 (US\$7) in the respective scenarios with the willingness-to-pay of US\$6610 per disability-adjusted life-year, corresponding to the average per capita GDP of Colombia between 2013 and 2017. Our results indicate that the effect of other control measures targeted to reduce ZIKV transmission decreases the range of vaccination costs for cost-effectiveness due to reduced returns of vaccine-induced herd immunity. In all scenarios investigated, the median reduction of microcephaly exceeded 64\% with vaccination. Conclusions: Our study suggests that a Zika vaccine with protection efficacy as low as 60\% could significantly reduce the incidence of microcephaly. From a government perspective, Zika vaccination is highly cost-effective, and even cost-saving in Colombia if vaccination costs per individual is sufficiently low. Efficacy data from clinical trials and number of vaccine doses will be important requirements in future studies to refine our estimates, and conduct similar studies in other at-risk populations.

Tags

Agent-based modeling Infection cost-effectiveness transmission disease Vaccination Infants Texas America Dengue Update Zika Microcephaly Virus outbreak Birth-defects Pregnancy