Conflicting objectives in trophy trout recreational fisheries: evaluating trade-offs using an individual-based model

Authored by Garcia-Asorey Martin Ignacio, Gabriela Escati-Penaloza, Parma Ana Maria, Pascual Miguel Alberto

Date Published: 2011

DOI: 10.1139/f2011-108

Sponsors: ANPCYT

Platforms: Microsoft Visual Basic

Model Documentation: Other Narrative Mathematical description

Model Code URLs: Model code not found

Abstract

Standard fisheries models, based on average population metrics, are inadequate for analyzing recreational fisheries where fishing is size-selective and management objectives are related to preserving population size structure. We developed a framework for policy analysis of size-based harvest strategies in recreational fisheries. The framework combines a mixed-effects body growth model and an individual-based harvest model to describe the relationship of growth, mortality, and size structure. Fishery performance is quantified with indicators directly associated to catch-related components of anglers' satisfaction: yield (kg), population size, and availability of trophy-size fish. We applied our analyses to the steelhead (Oncorhynchus mykiss) fishery in the Santa Cruz River (Patagonia, Argentina). Large declines in trophy-size fish are to be expected at fishing mortalities much too low to cause a sizeable decline in recruitment from virgin values. When somatic growth is density-independent, harvest occurs at the expense of other indicators associated with the quality of fishing experienced by individual anglers. Size limits provide a tool to better accommodate harvest without compromising fishing quality. When preserving population size is favored over preserving trophy-size fish, minimum size limits constitute the best policy overall, whereas maximum size limits are best when the emphasis is on preserving trophy-size fish.

Tags

Management Regulations population growth Variability Rainbow-trout Mixed-effects models Catch-and-release Size limits Argentina