Informed herbivore movement and interplant communication determine the effects of induced resistance in an individual-based model

Authored by Stephen P Ellner, Ilan N Rubin, Andre Kessler, Kimberly A Morrell

Date Published: 2015

DOI: 10.1111/1365-2656.12369

Sponsors: United States National Science Foundation (NSF)

Platforms: R

Model Documentation: Other Narrative

Model Code URLs: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/store/10.1111/1365-2656.12369/asset/supinfo/jane12369-sup-0002-DataS1.zip?v=1&s=0e29864755e5c8962c359da5484fc50bd3589443

Abstract

Plant induced resistance to herbivory affects the spatial distribution of herbivores, as well as their performance. In recent years, theories regarding the benefit to plants of induced resistance have shifted from ideas of optimal resource allocation towards a more eclectic set of theories that consider spatial and temporal plant variability and the spatial distribution of herbivores among plants. However, consensus is lacking on whether induced resistance causes increased herbivore aggregation or increased evenness, as both trends have been experimentally documented. We created a spatial individual-based model that can describe many plant-herbivore systems with induced resistance, in order to analyse how different aspects of induced resistance might affect herbivore distribution, and the total damage to a plant population, during a growing season. We analyse the specific effects on herbivore aggregation of informed herbivore movement (preferential movement to less-damaged plants) and of information transfer between plants about herbivore attacks, in order to identify mechanisms driving both aggregation and evenness. We also investigate how the resulting herbivore distributions affect the total damage to plants and aggregation of damage. Even, random and aggregated herbivore distributions can all occur in our model withinduced resistance. Highest levels of aggregation occurred in the models with informed herbivore movement, and the most even distributions occurred when the average number of herbivores per plant was low. With constitutive resistance, only random distributions occur. Damage to plants was spatially correlated, unless plants recover very quickly from damage; herbivore spatial autocorrelation was always weak. Our model and results provide a simple explanation for the apparent conflict between experimental results, indicating that both increased aggregation and increased evenness of herbivores can result from induced resistance. We demonstrate that information transfer from plants to herbivores, and from plants to neighbouring plants, can both be major factors in determining non-random herbivore distributions.

Tags

Evolution Coexistence Aggregation Plant Damage Spatial-distribution Solidago-altissima l. Insect herbivores Airborne signals Induced defenses