Beyond Corroboration: Strengthening Model Validation by Looking for Unexpected Patterns

Authored by Romain Reuillon, Clementine Cottineau, Guillaume Cherel

Date Published: 2015

DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0138212

Sponsors: European Research Council (ERC)

Platforms: OpenMOLE

Model Documentation: ODD Mathematical description

Model Code URLs: https://github.com/guillaumecherel/PSEExperiments

Abstract

Models of emergent phenomena are designed to provide an explanation to global-scale phenomena from local-scale processes. Model validation is commonly done by verifying that the model is able to reproduce the patterns to be explained. We argue that robust validation must not only be based on corroboration, but also on attempting to falsify the model, i.e. making sure that the model behaves soundly for any reasonable input and parameter values. We propose an open-ended evolutionary method based on Novelty Search to look for the diverse patterns a model can produce. The Pattern Space Exploration method was tested on a model of collective motion and compared to three common a priori sampling experiment designs. The method successfully discovered all known qualitatively different kinds of collective motion, and performed much better than the a priori sampling methods. The method was then applied to a case study of city system dynamics to explore the model's predicted values of city hierarchisation and population growth. This case study showed that the method can provide insights on potential predictive scenarios as well as falsifiers of the model when the simulated dynamics are highly unrealistic.

Tags